The story of Birdsong, created mixed responses in our readers. Firstly, thank you to Ruth for choosing a novel which provided a different insight into the suffering and trauma of war on the human spirit and psyche.
The story which traverses 3 generations, captures within its characters a currency of emotional detachment. A yearning for closeness and intimacy, yet it seems that the there is an emotional void which is not quite able to be navigated, to allow for true contentment. The author holds the reader in this emotional neverland only to bring you startling back to a brutal raw awareness of what it means to be vulnerable through his graphic descriptions of the soldiers experience in the trenches.
My personal reflection is, I appreciated the story, yet the characters' i could not quite connect with. I could never quite surrender to the voice of the characters and submerge myself in their world. That was a disappointment for me asafter reading the foreward, where i was mesmorised by the author's story of how he came to write the story, i think it left me wanting.
Ruth noted how she appreciated the new dimension of history provided in relaton to the "tunnelling" as this hadn't been explored as much in other historical fiction pieces she had read on WWI.
We found ourselves in agreement about not having a strong image of Stephen in our own mind, in spite of the detail provided about his character throughout the book.
We noted how the graphic detail of the warfare was shocking in its detail and at times more than Jen (*wincing as she read) would have preferred to be exposed to, and yet it provided a salient and humbling reminder of the severity of warfare on communities, civilisation and the individual. The story itself, provided a lot to discuss in terms of the power and impact of war.
The intergenerational story and re-emerging themes related to love and loyalty and the need to be connected, stimulated a great deal of discussion even to discussion about present generations, and what it means to know our history, how it influences and shapes us in the present and future.
A good first read - No regrets! Although I don't think we are all as positive in our regard for this book as those who have been rating it as "a spectacular...exceptional... best..read".